What implications could the SEC’s action against Binance have for other cryptocurrency exchanges?

On June 14, 2021, the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) announced that it had sued cryptocurrency platform Binance for operating an unregistered securities exchange. This move marked the SEC’s latest effort to expand its regulatory reach in the cryptocurrency market.

The SEC alleges that Binance, one of the world’s largest cryptocurrency exchanges, “failed to register its marketplace as a national securities exchange or seek an exemption from registration.” This is despite the fact that the exchange has enabled about $115 billion worth of cryptocurrency transactions over the past three years.

The SEC’s action against Binance comes amid a broader regulatory effort to crack down on unregistered securities. Earlier this year, the regulator charged Ripple Labs, the company behind the XRP cryptocurrency, with raising billions of dollars in unregistered digital asset sales.

The SEC maintains that cryptocurrency exchanges offering trading of digital assets should be registered with the agency or obtain an exemption from registration as required by the federal securities laws. While the SEC has long taken a diplomatically conservative approach toward such regulation, it appears to be strengthening its stance given the growing prominence of cryptocurrencies.

Moreover, the SEC’s recent charges and litigation against Binance could pave the way for other crypto exchanges to register with the agency or take measures to comply with registration requirements. This could lead to greater transparency and better consumer protection in the sector.

In a public statement, SEC Division of Enforcement Director Stephanie Avakian said, “It is important for platforms offering digital asset securities transactions to register with the SEC or seek an exemption.” She added that the regulator’s latest enforcement action “demonstrates that the SEC is vigilant in enforcing the registration provisions of the federal securities laws in the digital asset market.”

The SEC’s action against Binance is a firm reminder that cryptocurrency exchanges must register with the agency to ensure compliance with applicable laws. Going forward, the agency’s efforts could lead to a more secure and reliable crypto market.
he expects a court ruling in weeks. The result could have major implications for US crypto rules.

Here are some of the biggest crypto coins viewed as securities by the SEC. Market values are taken from CoinGecko.

–With assistance from Dave Liedtka.

(Adds comment from Kraken in the 9th paragraph.)

Most Read from Bloomberg Businessweek

The Securities and Exchange Commission’s list of digital tokens deemed as unregistered securities now spans over $115 billion of crypto after the US agency’s lawsuit against Binance Holdings Ltd. The regulator in the complaint on Monday cited a dozen coins as assets that fall under its purview, with strict investor protection rules that could make the tokens harder to trade if exchanges shy away from listing them for fear of falling foul of the SEC.

Binance’s BNB — which has a market value of $44 billion — stablecoin BUSD, Cardano’s ADA, Solana’s SOL, Polygon’s MATIC, Filecoin’s FIL and Algorand’s ALGO were among those mentioned in the lawsuit. When added to other tokens like XRP separately targeted by the SEC, the agency has now categorized over $115 billion of coins specifically as unregistered securities.

SEC Chair Gary Gensler has long said most tokens are subject to the agency’s investor-protection laws and that trading platforms should register with the regulator. But labeling specific tokens represents a tougher approach. US officials have cracked down on digital assets this year following a rout in 2022 and a series of blowups, including the bankruptcy of the FTX exchange.

The SEC’s action could have major implications for US crypto rules, with Coinbase, Kraken and other US-based exchanges having to make a decision on whether to delist, and US market makers potentially having to stop making markets on some of the tokens being listed as securities. Filecoin is down some 10% in the wake of the SEC’s complaint, while BNB has shed about 9%. The other assets mentioned are also nursing losses. In wider digital-asset markets, both Bitcoin and a gauge of the top 100 coins have fallen approximately 6%.

One of the key SEC cases is a 2020 lawsuit against Ripple Labs Inc. The complaint alleges the firm failed to register XRP as a security. Ripple’s Chief Executive Officer Brad Garlinghouse said in late May that he expects a court ruling in weeks. The result could have major implications for US crypto rules.

The SEC’s crackdown on digital assets this year has been a wake-up call for the crypto industry, with the agency’s labeling of specific tokens representing a tougher approach. With Coinbase, Kraken and other US-based exchanges having to make a decision on whether to delist, and US market makers potentially having to stop making markets on some of the tokens being listed as securities, the implications of the SEC’s action could be far-reaching.